ASPCA - Designing Adoption Around Confidence

ASPCA - Designing Adoption Around Confidence

ASPCA - Designing Adoption Around Confidence

ROLE · UX Designer | CATEGORY · Animal Welfare | TIMELINE · Sep 2025 – Nov 2025 | ORGANIZATION · World Studios at UC San Diego

My role: I audited the ASPCA website and customer reviews, redesigned pet profiles with photos, vaccination information, and behavioral details, and added search filters for kids, other pets, and size. I tested the redesign with 10 participants.

ASPCA project cover
ASPCA project cover

The Problem: High Intent, High Friction

Adoption isn't browsing. Potential adopters need enough context to picture an animal in their home and feel confident before applying, but the ASPCA's site put that entire burden on the user. Profiles offered a single photo and brief notes. Search had no filters for real-life constraints. Applications redirected to third-party shelter sites, forcing adopters to restart the process for every animal they considered.

Three breakdowns defined the failure:

  • Vague Profiles. Listings lacked trustworthy detail on health, behavior, and care needs.

  • Generic Search. Results ignored constraints like apartment rules or work schedules.

  • Fragmented Applications. External redirects punished anyone considering more than one pet.

Research and Early Concepts

I audited the ASPCA website and customer reviews to identify where people lost confidence before applying. Early user flows and low-fidelity concepts helped the team compare richer profiles, lifestyle-based search, and a unified application before committing to a direction.

Sketching for Confidence

We translated these findings into three early concepts: richer profiles, lifestyle-based search, and a unified application. Low-fidelity exploration helped us compare structures before committing to a direction.

ASPCA pet-profile wireframe exploration

Pet profile exploration

ASPCA search and filtering wireframe exploration

Search and filtering

ASPCA unified adoption application wireframe exploration

Unified application

The Solution: Designing for Decision Confidence

A Profile That Answers Real Questions
Many listings showed a single outdated photo, often from when the animal was a baby. I redesigned pet profiles with photos, vaccination information, and behavioral details so adopters could assess compatibility before applying.

Improved Searching
I added search filters for compatibility with kids and other pets, and size. Participants said this made it easier to find animals that actually matched their situation.

One Application
We replaced the third-party redirect with a single application built on a shared profile, so applying to a second or third shelter took one click instead of a full form. The redesigned adoption-inquiry flow had higher completion in testing than the original. We then added a clear confirmation step for each shelter to align the interface with participants’ expectations about where their application was being sent.

One Application
We replaced the third-party redirect with a single application built on a shared profile, so applying to a second or third shelter took one click instead of a full form. The redesigned adoption-inquiry flow had higher completion in testing than the original. We then added a clear confirmation step for each shelter to align the interface with participants’ expectations about where their application was being sent.

One Application
We replaced the third-party redirect with a single application built on a shared profile, so applying to a second or third shelter took one click instead of a full form. The redesigned adoption-inquiry flow had higher completion in testing than the original. We then added a clear confirmation step for each shelter to align the interface with participants’ expectations about where their application was being sent.

Outcome and Limitations

We tested the original site against the redesigned prototype with 10 participants (6 returning, 4 new), recruited through friends of friends and online communities.

Original. 2 of 10 completed the original adoption-inquiry flow.
Redesigned. 10 of 10 completed the redesigned adoption-inquiry flow, with 2 pausing to verify shared profile details.

Some improvement likely reflects familiarity, and the recruitment pool skews toward people already comfortable with digital applications. Even so, participants consistently pointed to structured details and saved profiles as what made the flow easier.

Usability Testing and Iteration

Our first version let users submit to multiple shelters with a single click. Testing revealed a flaw: participants assumed the ASPCA reviewed and forwarded applications centrally, rather than individual shelters receiving them directly. We added an explicit confirmation step for each shelter. The extra click was worth it because aligning the interface with participants’ expectations helps reduce confusion.

Reflection

We assumed the barrier to adoption was hesitation around commitment. Research showed it was informational: people were ready to commit but lacked the clarity to decide. If we expanded this project, we'd focus on comparing multiple pets side-by-side and optimizing the backend workflow for shelter staff.

Other projects

Other projects

© 2026 Jeffrey Liang